One piece of parenting advice has become very popular over the past decade.
"Give your children more choices."
Let them choose their clothes.
Let them choose their shoes.
Let them choose their stationery.
Let them choose what to eat.
The idea sounds reasonable. Giving children choices is supposed to build independence.
I agree—but only to a certain point.
Because I don't think every choice is valuable.
In fact, I think too many unnecessary choices can quietly create a different problem.
Many of these decisions don't actually teach children anything meaningful. Choosing between a blue pencil and a green pencil doesn't build judgment. Choosing between white shoes and black shoes rarely develops independence. Most of the time, children simply choose what they like.
There is nothing wrong with preference.
But preference is not a life skill.
What concerns me more is something else.
When children repeatedly experience getting the option they prefer, they slowly become accustomed to the idea that life usually adapts to what they want.
Not because they are spoiled.
Simply because that becomes their normal experience.
Then one day, reality begins to look different.
The answer is no.
The toy isn't bought.
The restaurant isn't chosen.
Someone else gets picked.
The trip doesn't happen.
And suddenly the emotional reaction feels much bigger than the situation itself.
I often see this happen with simple family activities.
Parents ask on Monday,
"What do you want to do this weekend?"
The child immediately begins imagining.
The zoo.
The beach.
The arcade.
The amusement park.
By Saturday morning, the parents decide to spend a relaxing afternoon at the local park.
Now the park feels disappointing.
Not because parks are boring.
But because expectations were already built days earlier.
Ironically, if the parents had simply said on Saturday morning,
"Let's go to the park."
Many children would probably have been excited.
Children naturally have an amazing ability to enjoy the present.
Sometimes, as adults, we unintentionally replace that with anticipation.
This is why I don't believe children need to choose everything.
Sometimes making the decision for them is not controlling.
It removes unnecessary expectations.
It allows them to enjoy the experience instead of comparing it with every other possibility that never happened.
This doesn't mean children should never make decisions.
It means we should be intentional about which decisions are actually worth giving.
Because one day they will face rejection.
Someone else will be selected.
A better idea will replace theirs.
The answer will simply be "no."
We cannot protect children from rejection forever.
But we can prepare them for it.
Sometimes that preparation begins by not giving a choice that never needed to exist in the first place.
0 comments